How to get shy students to pitch with confidence

Shy students pitch better when the format gives them structure and an out. Here are the techniques that consistently work.

Education
Darby Rollins
May 2, 2026
3 min

Q: How do you get shy students to pitch with confidence?

To get shy students to pitch with confidence: start with team pitches before solo, use a memorized 4-sentence pitch as the spine, allow notecards, run low-stakes peer rounds before public ones, and praise structure over charisma. Confidence follows competence, not the other way around.

The story

The shy student problem is one of the most underestimated in pitch teaching. The fix is structural. Start them in team pitches so they're not alone onstage. Use a memorized 4-sentence pitch (problem, solution, who, why now) as the spine so they have a script when nerves hit. Allow notecards. Run small peer rounds before any public stakes. Praise structure visibly so they know how to win without having to be the loudest. SideHustle LIVE Labs uses team-based rounds in the 90-minute Labs format with 4-5 students per team and Funny + Fundable scoring. It has run as one-time activations at Mars Hill, the University of Oklahoma, Penn State, Xavier, and the University of Wisconsin. For the deeper teaching method see how to teach pitching to high school students. Confidence is downstream of structure.

What it means

If you have shy students who freeze, don't push them onto a solo stage. Build the structure first. Team pitches, memorized spine, notecards allowed, peer judging. By round three, the shy ones often surprise everyone, themselves included.

Try it

Sign Up TO PLAY!
Enter your email to play SideHustle® FREE.
We will never sell your info.
sideHustle Party Game